Cars4us

2024 Polestar 4 vs 2024 Tesla Model Y

Published March 2025
2024 Polestar 4 vs 2024 Tesla Model Y
2024 Polestar 4 vs 2024 Tesla Model Y
2024 Polestar 4 vs 2024 Tesla Model Y Close

A Comprehensive Cars Comparison by Cars4us

The battle for supremacy in the electric SUV segment has never been fiercer, with the 2024 Polestar 4 and Tesla Model Y at the forefront of innovation, luxury, and performance. Both vehicles showcase cutting-edge technology and eco-conscious design, but they cater to slightly different needs and preferences. Let’s dive into the details and compare these two EVs across six critical categories—performance, range and charging, interior design and technology, safety, pricing, and value—to help you decide which electric SUV fits your lifestyle.

Performance

2024 Polestar 4

9.5/10

  • Powertrain: Dual-motor all-wheel drive (AWD).
  • Horsepower: Up to 544 hp (Performance variant).
  • Acceleration: 0-100 km/h in 3.8 seconds.
  • Driving Dynamics: Features Polestar's adaptive damping suspension and a near 50/50 weight distribution for excellent handling.
  • The Polestar 4 focuses on blending luxury and high performance, with its dual-motor system delivering a thrilling driving experience. Its adaptive suspension ensures smooth handling across various terrains, making it ideal for both city streets and open highways.

Tesla Model Y

9/10

  • Powertrain: Dual-motor AWD (Performance variant).
  • Horsepower: Up to 456 hp.
  • Acceleration: 0-100 km/h in 3.7 seconds.
  • Driving Dynamics: Tesla’s low centre of gravity and sport-tuned suspension contribute to agile and responsive handling.
  • The Tesla Model Y is engineered for speed and agility. Its quick acceleration and precise steering make it feel like a sports car disguised as an SUV, but the ride can feel a bit firm for some drivers.

Range and Charging

2024 Polestar 4

9/10

  • Range: Up to 560 km (WLTP).
  • Battery: 102 kWh capacity.
  • Charging: Supports up to 200 kW DC fast charging (10-80% in 30 minutes).
  • Polestar 4 delivers competitive range and charging speeds, designed for long-distance road trips and rapid recharges at high-powered stations.

Tesla Model Y

9.5/10

  • Range: Up to 533 km (WLTP, Long Range variant).
  • Battery: 75 kWh capacity.
  • Charging: Supports up to 250 kW DC fast charging (10-80% in ~25 minutes).
  • The Model Y benefits from Tesla’s Supercharger network, which ensures fast and reliable charging at thousands of locations globally. While its battery capacity is smaller than Polestar’s, its charging speeds are faster.

Interior Design and Technology

2024 Polestar 4

9.5/10

  • Seating: Luxurious vegan upholstery and optional Nappa leather with ventilation and massage functions.
  • Infotainment: 15.4-inch centre display running on Android Automotive OS with Google integration.
  • Features: Heads-up display (HUD), 14-speaker Harman Kardon sound system, and panoramic glass roof with smart dimming.
  • The Polestar 4’s minimalist Scandinavian design exudes elegance, with premium materials and a focus on sustainability. Its Android-based infotainment system is intuitive and seamlessly integrates with Google Maps and voice controls.

Tesla Model Y

9/10

  • Seating: Synthetic leather upholstery with heating for all seats.
  • Infotainment: 15-inch touchscreen with Tesla’s proprietary OS.
  • Features: Over-the-air (OTA) software updates, immersive sound system, and a full-glass roof.
  • Tesla’s cabin design is simple and futuristic, with its single touchscreen acting as the command centre. While functional, its lack of physical controls might take some getting used to for first-time Tesla owners.

Safety Features

2024 Polestar 4

9.5/10

  • Safety Suite: Pilot Assist, lane-keeping aid, adaptive cruise control, and rear cross-traffic alert.
  • Additional Features: 12 cameras, five radar systems, and 12 ultrasonic sensors for 360-degree awareness.
  • Crash Ratings: Yet to be tested (expected to score highly based on Polestar’s reputation).
  • Polestar takes safety seriously, incorporating advanced driver-assistance systems (ADAS) and ensuring robust construction with safety as a priority.

Tesla Model Y

9.5/10

  • Safety Suite: Tesla Autopilot, lane departure warning, and automatic emergency braking.
  • Additional Features: Full Self-Driving (FSD) capability (optional) and Tesla Vision for advanced object detection.
  • Crash Ratings: 5-star ANCAP rating.
  • Tesla’s Autopilot and optional FSD features offer semi-autonomous driving capabilities, though regulatory limitations mean they’re not fully self-driving yet.

Price and Value

2024 Polestar 4

8.5/10

  • Starting Price: AUD $89,000.
  • Warranty: 5 years/unlimited km.
  • The Polestar 4 provides excellent value for those seeking a balance of luxury, performance, and cutting-edge technology without breaking the bank.

Tesla Model Y

9.5/10

  • Starting Price: AUD $78,000.
  • Warranty: 4 years/80,000 km.
  • The Tesla Model Y is more affordable, making it a practical entry point into the EV market for buyers looking for strong performance and tech features.

Our Verdict

9.2/10
Tesla Model 3 9.3/10

2024 Polestar 4: Perfect for buyers who value premium interiors, longer range, and refined driving dynamics. Its Scandinavian elegance and attention to detail make it a top choice for those who want more than just an EV—it’s an experience.

2024 Tesla Model Y: Ideal for those seeking cutting-edge technology, faster charging, and a more accessible price point. Tesla’s Supercharger network and OTA updates remain strong selling points.

Ultimately, the choice between the Polestar 4 and Tesla Model Y comes down to your priorities. The Polestar 4 excels in luxury and range, while the Model Y offers tech innovation and affordability. Whichever you choose, both EVs represent the future of sustainable transportation.

You might also be interested in...